Adam Cohen, a 36-year-old Manhattan ad executive and Yankees fan, has passed on a lot of passions to his 8-year-old son, Marc: comic books, “Star Wars” and all things Disney. But baseball isn’t one of them.
“I think baseball is too slow for Marc,” Cohen said. “He just gets bored. If we are at a game, he picks up an iPhone so that he can entertain himself. It’s more engaging . . . Why watch other people [play a game] when you can do something yourself?”
Even after an epic 2016 World Series in which the Chicago Cubs claimed the title for the first time in 108 years and 40 million tuned in for Game 7 — making it the most-watched baseball game since 1991 — critics of the sport are still crying foul.
They say it’s too male, too white, too old. Of the top major sports, baseball has the oldest spectators; half of its audience today is 55 or older, an increase from 41 percent a decade ago, according to Nielsen.
Yes, video games and iPhones, which offer instant gratification and an interactive experience, are partly to blame. But there are also increasingly fewer major-league games that kids can actually watch live, with matchups rarely ending before 11 or midnight.
“There are fewer day games and fewer weekend day games,” Cohen said. “Even in the summer it’s tough to go to games at night . . . kids have camp.”
But the biggest complaint of baseball fans — both young and old — is that the pace of the game is too sluggish. According to statistics Web site FiveThirtyEight, one block of 27 games last season had an average length of 3 hours and 24 minutes — the highest continuous average in such a block in five years — with some games stretching beyond four hours.
With struggles like these, it’s no surprise that many are saying the game’s appeal is out in left field.
So who or what is to blame for baseball games that go on forever? Two oft-cited culprits are constant replay calls and batters who leave the box in between every pitch to adjust their gloves and helmet and shin guards and elbow pads and then knock the dirt off their cleats before working up their stride for the next at-bat.
Of the top major sports, baseball has the oldest spectators; half of its audience today is 55 or older, an increase from 41 percent a decade ago.
Major League Baseball has added some rule changes to speed up these two aspects of the game. One new rule, put in place last year, prohibits batters from stepping out of the box with every pitch, tightening up the time between innings. Meanwhile, managers who used to make a long show of their displeasure over a call before actually demanding a replay are now forced to make their minds up: As of this year, they have just 30 seconds to decide whether they want to issue a challenge — and even when a replay review is granted, umpires have just two minutes to make a ruling.
Pitchers intentionally walking batters is also a bore, forcing fans to watch four balls thrown to the catcher out of the strike zone even when the result is clearly predetermined. For this, a “no-pitch intentional walk” rule has been added this year, allowing a team manager to automatically send a batter to first base without four balls being thrown.
Fans also frequently complain about slow-paced pitchers. There are also too many pitching changes, and with every new relief pitcher coming in, more warm-up tosses that hang up the game. But it’s actually umpires who might present the greater problem.
Since 2008, umpires have become more generous with the strike zone, enabling it to go a few inches below the knees of a hitter, according to a study by Brian Mills, an assistant professor at the University of Florida who examined umpire data from 1998 to 2013. This has increased strikeouts — and, as a result, decreased the action on the field.
“That’s been a partial driver of the decrease in scoring over the past 10 -or 15 years,” Mills said.
So what can fix the ambiguity of the strike zone, ensuring that it’s always consistent?
Machines.