Likability is one of those dreaded buzzwords that plagues complicated female characters like Lena Dunham’s Hannah Horvath, (another possible candidate for TV’s greatest female antihero) who is, in the end, merely a flawed human, not a multi-dimensional villain. But while the UnREAL writers’ room may not have been concerned with likability, Appleby, with her doe eyes and cute little face, is someone we want to like. Rachel, the character, plays up that persona while constantly manipulating everyone around her—but particularly the china-doll contestants on the show—into giving her what she wants. Her most oft-used phrase is “as a friend,” which she deploys just before dispensing advice that pushes people right into the palm of her hand.
And Rachel can be a good person. Sometimes. Unlike the scheming contestants on her show, her cut-throat fellow producers, and her heartless boss (played with delicious villainy by Constance Zimmer), Rachel has a heart. We see it clearly when she tries to protect closeted contestant Faith. But we also see her lie to contestant Anna about her dying father and push unstable contestant Mary into a confrontation with her abusive ex. If all of this sounds excessively soapy, that’s because it is. But Appleby’s astonishing performance slices right through the suds.
It’s that push and pull of likable meek persona and terrifying manipulative mastermind that makes Rachel, like Walter White before her, such a compelling character. Repulsive-yet-relatable is a hard combination to pull off, yet Appleby manages. And just like White, Rachel is in this entirely for herself. When speaking with Vanity Fair’s Julie Miller, Appleby described the real-life reality-show producer she used as an inspiration for her character:
I asked her every question I could possibly think of about her job and
what it meant to her and you could see that she really got off on it.
Even though it was something that made her feel ugly at times and made
her feel bad about what she was doing. I think she got a high off the
fact that she could make all of these people do what she wanted to do.
You could feel that it was almost like a hunger inside of her.